Non-Christians were issued with the unaltered version of the badge (see for example https://asiamedals.info/threads/order-of-the-white-eagle-with-diamonds-awarded-in-1913-to-general-albert-damade.26638/). Only the central medallion of the issued breast star was different.
Gold, silver, gilt...
carl bolin
order of the white eagle for non-christians
order of the white eagle with diamonds
звезда ордена белогоорладлянехристиан
иноверческий русский императорский орден
карл болин
орденбелогоорладлянехристианорденбелогоорласбриллиантамиорденбелогоорласбриллиантамидлянехристианордендлянехристиан